SPRING’S FIRST MAYFLY: BAETIS

 

It’s been a warmer than average winter, and nature’s creatures notice things like that.  Winter birds, which normally flock to the feeder in front of my house, have remained strangely absent this year, until last night’s cold-snap and miniature blizzard brought them out in force this morning.  The snow-free countryside had made natural food more available to the birds, so, until now, they weren’t interested in seeds from a bag.  And another sign of an unusually mild winter has recently appeared: reports of a few Little Blue Winged Olives began trickling into the fly shop a little more than a week ago.

For many trout, Baetis are the first and last mayfly hatch they see each year.  The Baetis hatch connects the seasons; the one that ended last fall and the one that is about to begin.  They remind me of a great October fishing trip last year when trout came easily to my net from water peppered by the occasional ruby-colored leaf.  The fish weren’t eating dries that day.  But a tandem of size 18 pheasant tails, slowly stripped like a wintertime streamer, evoked strikes from wild browns that believed they were eating one of the many Baetis nymphs I could see moving to resting areas behind boulders, preparing to emerge.  Perhaps it was those very flies that gave birth to the Baetis the anglers in my shop are seeing this year.

The central Pennsylvania spring creeks, which ooze from the karst geology beneath local valley floors, maintain water temperatures much warmer in the winter than the freestone streams that tumble out of the nearby Appalachian Mountains.  This means that during an average winter, anglers will find Baetis in our brown trout streams well before the possibility of mayfly hatches exist for most brook trout.  Mid February Baetis emergences, though not common, occur from time to time in Central Pennsylvania.  But early February hatches are much less common.  Whether this phenomenon is caused by an increasingly warming planet, or by the the new-to-me weather contributor known as the Arctic Oscillation, is left to be determined by those smarter than I am.  But the bugs aren’t interested in why.  They are simply here.

The hatch hasn’t really revealed itself, yet.  It’s still in a  junior high school stage with a few advanced members developing ahead of the others.  A quick examination of stream-bottom rocks shows that most of the flies are just not ready.  Look at the Baetis nymph in the photograph below:

 

I shot this photo earlier this week.  This nymph’s wing-pads will transform from its current mottled-olive color to dark brown, near black, as the dun develops beneath its exoskeleton.  Then this Baetis will hatch.  When many begin to hatch, the trout will notice, and after the trout notice, they will begin to eat them in the slow pools.  And then, no matter what the calendar says, another spring has arrived for fly fishers.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  • FlyGuy

    Great blog, thanks for the info. I am so looking forward to spring, no matter how mild the winter has been.

  • MarkH

    Great Post. I will be tying up my BWO selection later this week. Really is a great hatch to start the spring with. Any patterns you have better luck with Paul?

    • Paul Weamer

      Thanks Mark! I really like CDC Comparaduns for these little olives, tied with a dark brown trailing shuck. You can use olive beaver dubbing for the body, or if you want to make it look really cool, an olive biot body looks, and works, great. I've also been tying them with twisted bucktail bodies. They're a little tough to describe here, but I wrote a story about them for the upcoming issue of Fly Fisherman mag. I would use olive thread twisted with 1 tan and 1 olive bucktail fiber to make the body. This method will make more sense after you see the article.

  • http://www.crosscurrentguideservice.com Joe Demalderis

    Paul,
    I usually don't see these bugs hatching until sometime in late March through April on the Delaware. The way this winter's been going maybe an earlier start could happen this year. Once the nymph shows its maturity with a dark wing case, how long do you figure before it will hatch?

    • Paul Weamer

      Hey Joe. Your observation about the timing of the little olives on the Delaware fits mine exactly. It's amazing how traveling 3 hours south, combined with streams full of warmer limestone water, can make such a big difference for the timing of hatches.

      The question about nymph maturity is a tough one to answer. There are so many variables. Generally, once the wings are fully developed, a nymph will hatch into a dun in anywhere from a few hours to a few days. But sudden weather changes can have a huge impact. Cold snaps in particular seem to slow their transformations.

      I've seen this often with Hendricksons. I've fished several mild days with Hendricksons emerging, then it gets really cold again, and the hatch doesn't show for a few days. I also believe that some nymphs get to a state where they are ready to emerge, but they don't. I think they have some control over this. How else do you explain why Blue Winged Olives love overcast rainy weather? They can't predict the weather, yet after several hot, sunny days, olives will suddenly appear when it rains.

      This isn't really science. Just a few of my own observations.

      • http://www.crosscurrentguideservice.com Joe Demalderis

        It all makes you wonder how anyone can bait fish for trout…

      • midnightAngler

        It's amazing how much nymphs are able to modify their behavior to adjust to changing conditions. I just read a paper which claimed that nymphs can detect nearby predators by smell, and that they actually modify their activities depending on the type of predator. Naturally, I decided to add a sculpin to the aquarium when I read about this – I tell you, those nymphs changed their behavior. They hang tight to the substrate and they don't swim around for fun half the day. A baetis nymph may not know much, but they know how to survive.

  • korbin

    One of my favorite hatches of the year………except the bikini hatch of course……I love little mayflies but also live big boobies!

  • LipRip'n Dries

    Awesome fly! Even rookie tyers can tie this fly. i started tying 2 years ago and this was one of my 1st flies1 Yes, it is a small fly which makes it somewhat harder to tie, but it is really a fly that everyone who has even minor knowledge of tying can tie. I tie these on size 16 normally and use black hackle for the tail. Then I just dub up the body, normally with superfine olive dry fly dubbing. About a little more then 3/4 up the hook i tie in either a CDc puff or polypropelene floating yarn as a parachute wing. Tie off the wing and tie in a small black whiting dry fly hackle just below the wing. wrap the hackle around the wing 4 or 5 times tie off and cut. then i dub a little more to cover up any thread or material ends and the rest of the bare hook, whip finish and vamose!
    I used the 1st BWO i ever tried at a creek in central pa and had a blast watching the fish surface to gulp it up! Not only was it the 1st time i evertied and fished the BWO, it was my first dry fly to tie period. it was also the VERY FIRST time to even fish with a dry fly at all! And I lost track of how many trout I landed after 12! Definitly a fly worth tying or buying if you want to catch fish on a dry.