Major Montana Access Win

Major Montana Access Win

MTWin

A major lawsuit regarding public access to fishing water that was in contention for nearly 20 years has been brought to resolution. With the potential to set legal precedent in both it's home state and across the US, the fight to defend historical entry to the Ruby River in southwestern Montana was a classic battle of popular vs. private interests.

A tributary of the Beaverhead River, the Ruby is a small steam with a long legacy as a fly fishing resource, and has bridges crossing it dating back to the Gold Rush. Public access to streams and rivers in Montana is protected by one of the most progressive laws in the country, which mandates that the public has the right to walk, wade and float most natural waterways up to the high water mark.  As a western fisherman, I've always admired the foresight that this statute represented in protection of the public good, and envied the access that it provided to anglers in Montana. The legislative vision has proved to be a clear one, as fishing is now a major driver of the economy in the state, and plays a strong role in the culture and values of the people there.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SpAm-0TUSI0


At issue is the matter of access to the water. While anglers in Montana have the right to be in the stream channel, getting to it is another matter entirely. Across the west, private lands in the form of historical ranches are being bought up and accreted into vast holdings with monolithic trespass policies, a departure from the historical accommodation that ranchers typically afforded to fishermen when they were polite -- and brave enough -- to ask for it. In my time in the Rocky Mountains, more often than not, if I asked for permission from a landowner to fish a property with a promise to pinch my barbs, release my fish, pick up trash and report any problems I saw, it was granted.  The few times I wasn't, I respected it, and never made the decision to jump fence. This was, admittedly, as much a consideration of getting a scatter-gun load of rock salt in the ass as it was of good manners.


The legal representation of the incorporated holdings that are spreading across the region are much less approachable than historical land users, and are of considerably more litigious nature. The case of the Ruby River issue appears to be a textbook example in this regard, with the current landowner of the surrounding property, James Cox Kennedy -- principle shareholder of Cox Communications, with a corporate net worth estimated at $18 billion -- versus advocates the Public Land / Water Access Association (PLWA).

When Kennedy bought the land surrounding the Ruby in the 1990's, he apparently directed barbed wire and electric fencing to be strung across historical access points alongside bridges and other put-in's, immediately raising the ire of locals and provoking the PLWA involvement.  During the course of the 12 year battle to resolve the dispute, at one point an attorney for the Kennedy estate stated that his client "owned the rights to the ground, the water and the air over the river", a claim that resulted in PLWA to file suit against the County that was in charge of management of the bridges in question, to invoke the question of public right of way associated with the publicly funded infrastructures.

Interestingly, Kennedy himself has cited his participation in environmental initiatives through the incorporation of a negotiated Conservation Easement associated with the Ruby River property, a legal apparatus traditionally intended to keep natural resources intact while providing benefits such as modest publicly funded financial supports and tax breaks to working ranchers and farmers who otherwise might be forced to sell or subdivide their holdings. However, Mr. Kennedy's sprawling vanity would seem to not have required any additional public incentives to maintain private fishing resources for himself and his friends. In this case, the installation of a Conservation Easement may have been merely a PR strategy on the part of his legal team, or could have intended to reinforce access restrictions.

Turnabout being strategic fair play, PLWA attorneys called for clarification of the legal standard regarding appropriate right of way being necessary for the maintenance and upkeep of the support elements and abutments of the bridges, which arguably could not be conducted without access to a reasonable amount of space on either side of the structures. After almost two decades of wrangling and the ultimate involvement of the Montana Supreme Court -- which remanded final elements of the case back down to the county level -- the issue has finally been resolved without fanfare by the recent passing of a deadline for appeals going uncontested. Anglers can now legally walk to the water via narrow ingress provided directly alongside the bridges.


"This is a milestone. It's a rebuttal of the attempt of a very rich individual to control access to streams in Montana. He was defeated by a bunch of volunteers." said John Gibson, president of the Public Land/water Access Association.

When personal venality starts to affect the rights and resources of the people, it's good to see that the resolve the PLWA showed in ultimately prevailing benefitted us all. A legal standard was set, but more importantly, so was an example.  With the new upcoming federal adminstration likely to tilt the political terrain in regards to public lands management, it may make the kind of battle required to save the Ruby River look like a dress rehearsal.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymRMX5ZQeuI


https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/4b/RubyRiver.jpg/200px-RubyRiver.jpg

http://www.plwa.org/images/mt_Public_Access_Luck.jpg

http://www.bigskyfishing.com/River-Fishing/SW-MT-Rivers/ruby-river/ruby-river-graphics/upper_ruby1.jpg

Get Your Fish On.

Plan your next fishing and boating adventure here.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Black Beauty

Black Beauty

Master fly tier Charlie Craven discuss the tools and materials needed to tie the Black Beauty.

Breaking the Surface

Breaking the Surface

Attack of the Bass continues as Breaking the Surface attacks bass with fly and lure 12:30pm ET Sunday, April 17th.

Casting Backhand in Tight Quarters

Casting Backhand in Tight Quarters

A backhand cast is when you use your backcast to deliver the fly.

Fly Fishing for Taimen in Mongolia

Fly Fishing for Taimen in Mongolia

Finding giant Mongolia taimen and a state of enlightenment.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

As you explore your home water, keep in mind what they are eating to select the best carp flies! Flies

The 15 Best Carp Flies

Jay Zimmerman - September 27, 2016

As you explore your home water, keep in mind what they are eating to select the best carp...

George Daniels offers his advice on which types of fly-fishing leaders are best for the most common applications you'll encounter on the water. Beginners

Picking the Perfect Fly-Fishing Leader

George Daniel - January 22, 2018

George Daniels offers his advice on which types of fly-fishing leaders are best for the most...

Drift boats help you search through miles of river quickly and effectively. Here's the top models on the market today. Gear

Top Drift Boats of 2019

John Fedorka - April 02, 2019

Drift boats help you search through miles of river quickly and effectively. Here's the top...

The fly fishing communities in the U.S. and Belize are mourning after twin slayings that occurred on what appeared to be a routine guide trip on Sunday, June 23, 2019 in a shallow lagoon near San Pedro, Brazil. Industry

Fly Fishing Community Stunned by Twin Slayings on Belize Saltwater Flat

Fly Fisherman Online Staff - June 27, 2019

The fly fishing communities in the U.S. and Belize are mourning after twin slayings that...

See More Trending Articles

More Industry

What do Donald Trump Jr. and Barack Obama have in common? Find out in Industry

Presidential Piscatorial Pursuits

Jonathan Wright - June 28, 2018

What do Donald Trump Jr. and Barack Obama have in common? Find out in "Presidential...

$20 Million will go to 1,000 grassroots organizations including CalTrout, BTT, and the Wild Salmon Center.
Industry

Patagonia Consumers Donate $10 Million, Company Will Match

Fly Fisherman - January 06, 2020

$20 Million will go to 1,000 grassroots organizations including CalTrout, BTT, and the Wild...

Fly fishing world mourns as news breaks of well-known midwestern guides Brian Schumacher and his wife Janet Veit losing their lives in a fishing mishap in the frigid waters of Iceland. Industry

Well-Known Fly Fishing Guides Perish Tragically in Fishing Accident

Lynn Burkhead - May 22, 2018

Fly fishing world mourns as news breaks of well-known midwestern guides Brian Schumacher and...

See More Industry

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

All Fly Fisherman subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now