Skip to main content

Pebble Mine Shot Down

Pebble Mine Shot Down
Ross Purnell photo

Pebble Mine won’t move forward as it’s currently proposed, says the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and both state senators. On Aug. 24, the Army Corps gave the Canadian-owned company Northern Dynasty Minerals 90 days to submit a “compensatory mitigation” plan to address “unavoidable adverse impacts" such as discharges into the Koktuli and Nushagak watersheds.

In 2014, the EPA under the Obama administration ruled that Northern Dynasty could not even apply for USACE permits for Pebble Mine because it could have “significant” and potentially “catastrophic” impacts to the Bristol Bay Region, the world’s most prolific Pacific salmon watershed. In 2017, under the Trump administration, EPA administrator Scott Pruitt promised to “provide Pebble a fair process for their permit application.”

However, after prominent Republicans like Nick Ayers and Donald Trump Jr. tweeted their opposition to the mine, and Fox News host Tucker Carlson hosted Bass Pro Shops owner Johnny Morris on his primetime show, President Donald Trump promised to “look at both sides of it.”

Just a few days later, on Aug. 24, USACE said it will “review the compensatory mitigation plan upon submittal to determine if the amount and type of compensatory mitigation offered is sufficient to offset the identified unavoidable adverse impacts to aquatic resources and overcome signifcant degradation at the mine site.”


USACE now estimates the mine site would directly or indirectly affect 2,825 acres of wetlands, 132.5 acres of open waters and 129.5 miles of streams, and discharges from its transportation corridor would impact 460 acres of wetlands, 231.7 acres of open waters and 55.5 miles of streams.


This is a very important development in the battle to stop the Pebble Mine, and will make it much harder for the Northern Dynasty to secure the permits it needs," said Guido Rahr, CEO of Wild Salmon Center. This also is the first time the Army Corps of Engineers has acknowledged that the mine will cause significant damage to the Bristol Bay watershed. No amount of mitigation can compensate for the long-term damage to these rivers, which support the most productive salmon fisheries on Earth."

Hours after the USACE published its new directive for a mitigation plan, both Alaska senators issued public statements.

“In this instance, after years of extensive process and scientific study, federal officials have determined the Pebble project, as proposed, does not meet the high bar for large-scale development in Bristol Bay,” wrote Senator Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska). “I understand, respect, and support this decision. I agree that a permit should not be issued. And I thank the administration for its commitment to the protection of this world-class watershed and salmon fishery.”

//content.osgnetworks.tv/flyfisherman/content/photos/Pebble-Mine-Bear.jpg
Ross Purnell photo

Senator Dan Sullivan (R-Alaska), who had been critical of the Obama Administration’s outright dismissal of the mine, also said that the current proposal is untenable.


“Throughout this process, I have advocated for the Army Corps and other federal regulatory agencies to conduct a rigorous, fair, science-based review—free of politics—that does not trade one resource for another. I have worked hard to ensure that the voices of all Alaskans—both for and against the Pebble Mine—would be heard, considered, and respected at the highest levels of the federal government. This has happened,” wrote Sullivan. “Finally, I have been clear that given the important aquatic system and world-class fishery resources at stake, Pebble, like all resource development projects in Alaska, has to pass a high bar— a bar that the Trump administration has determined Pebble has not met. I support this conclusion—based on the best available science and a rigorous, fair process— that a federal permit cannot be issued.

Pebble Limited Partnership CEO Tom Collier in a written statement Aug. 24 claimed nothing had changed: “Based on our understanding of the substance of the letter, our discussions with the state, our substantial work in the field and our discussions with the USACE we believe our final Comprehensive Management Plan submission will be submitted within weeks and will satisfy all of the requirements of the letter. A clear reading of the letter shows it is entirely unrelated to recent tweets about Pebble and one-sided news shows. The White House had nothing to do with the letter ... This is the next step in what has been a comprehensive, exhaustive two-and-a-half-year review of the project. Nothing in the letter is a surprise to us or them.”

Get Your Fish On.

Plan your next fishing and boating adventure here.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

RIO Slickcast Fly Lines

RIO Slickcast Fly Lines

Chris Walker, with RIO Products, talks with Editor/Publisher Ross Purnell of Fly Fisherman magazine about the new SlickCast lineup of fly lines for 2020.

Rio Technical Trout

Rio Technical Trout

Rio Technical Trout

Tying the Double Barrel Popper

Tying the Double Barrel Popper

All these tricks can be put to use on poppers or sliders for anything with fins, from panfish to billfish.

Yeti Roadie

Yeti Roadie

Ross Purnell talks with Fly Fisherman contributor Hilary Hutcheson about the new Yeti Roadie.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

It's a land of beautiful rivers, friendly people, and like a magnet it will draw you back.South Island: The Mount Everest of Trout Fishing Worldwide

South Island: The Mount Everest of Trout Fishing

Barry Beck | Photography & Text - September 25, 2019

It's a land of beautiful rivers, friendly people, and like a magnet it will draw you back.

George Daniels offers his advice on which types of fly-fishing leaders are best for the most common applications you'll encounter on the water.Picking the Perfect Fly-Fishing Leader Beginners

Picking the Perfect Fly-Fishing Leader

George Daniel

George Daniels offers his advice on which types of fly-fishing leaders are best for the most...

This line control is one of the unique aspects of fly fishing.How to Mend, Set the Hook, and Strip Line Beginners

How to Mend, Set the Hook, and Strip Line

Landon Mayer | Illustrations by Joe Mahler - August 11, 2020

This line control is one of the unique aspects of fly fishing.

How to deliver meat & potatoes to hungry troutTools for Streamer Fishing Beginners

Tools for Streamer Fishing

George Daniel - February 10, 2020

How to deliver meat & potatoes to hungry trout

See More Trending Articles

More Conservation

Social media, films, magazines, and online publications tout seldom-fished waters and high fish numbers on prized streams these days.Solving River Conflicts Conservation

Solving River Conflicts

Boots Allen

Social media, films, magazines, and online publications tout seldom-fished waters and high...

The Bristol Bay region constitutes the world's largest sockeye salmon fishery.Time for EPA to Veto Pebble Mine Conservation

Time for EPA to Veto Pebble Mine

Fly Fisherman - July 24, 2020

The Bristol Bay region constitutes the world's largest sockeye salmon fishery.

Pebble Mine won't move forward as it's currently proposed.Pebble Mine Shot Down Conservation

Pebble Mine Shot Down

Fly Fisherman Staff - August 25, 2020

Pebble Mine won't move forward as it's currently proposed.

See More Conservation

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Fly Fisherman subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now