The Peripheral Effects of Hatcheries on NW Rivers

The Peripheral Effects of Hatcheries on NW Rivers
Photo courtesy of Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife

OSU Professor Dr. Michael Blouin was quoted in the Oregonian story mentioned in yesterday's Spey Today post stating, "In my opinion, the question of whether genetic change occurs in hatcheries has been answered," Blouin said. "If we could quit arguing about that and find out why, then we're all on the same team again."

Blouin's statement contains a book-length argument.  It followed me fishing recently, echoing again and again as I fished a run widely known to hold broodstock as well as wild steelhead.  Here Blouin points out that we anglers are divided in to two camps, hatchery-supporters and hatchery-detractors.  This divide, at least on the rivers I frequent, often seems to parallel the (over-emphasized) division between gear and fly anglers, which works to infuse the argument with hints of larger social/political divisions.  On this particular day, I was asked by the state fisheries managers if I would help them capture wild fish for the broodstock program--something they request from most guides on the river--and something this guide politely refused.

But Blouin's statement moves past the stale divisions, and advocates for a position that he assumes all of us anglers can get behind: hatcheries producing steelhead that are genetically identical to those spawned and reared naturally.

On my first pass through the run--my fly turning broadside and swimming over the boulders--I was deeply attracted to Blouin's notion.  Imagine, hatcheries living up to their initial promise: creating thousands more steelhead for us to catch without harming the remaining wild steelhead...  But then on my second pass through the run, the initial shine of Blouin's idea wore thin for me.


Photo courtesy of Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife


Part of the problem has to do with habitat; for as long as we have hatcheries on our rivers, millions of angler-dollars will continue to go to mass-producing fish instead of repairing the habitat losses (i.e. lack of large wood in river and estuary, lack of shoreside cover, excessive silt run-off, etc).  And then there is the fiscal inefficiency of hatcheries: each returning adult hatchery steelhead costs hundreds to produce (one federal audit of Mitchell-funded hatcheries found that each returning adult winter steelhead costs $255). Hatcheries mask the symptom without curing the disease.


But more than that, as long as we have hatcheries, anglers will continue to shirk their responsibilities to the watersheds they fish; instead of working to create conservation easements--instead of working together to protect native fish--we'll fight with each other about smolt stockings.

As I finished the run and walked back up to the boat, I realized though that I am not "anti-hatchery," despite my reservations about Blouin's statement. I do see a role for hatcheries on Northwest rivers--just not on rivers that still sustain native populations.  And unfortunately, we have far too many of those rivers.   One thing we can all agree on is we'd like to keep that number from growing.

Get Your Fish On.

Plan your next fishing and boating adventure here.

Recommended for You

Modern methods for catching smallmouths on topwater flies. Bass

How to Catch Smallmouth Bass on Topwater Flies

Dave Karczynski and Tim Landwehr

Modern methods for catching smallmouths on topwater flies.

How an Atlanta craft brewery is helping to save Georgia's most important trout stream. United States

Saving the Chattahoochee River

Ross Purnell - April 23, 2019

How an Atlanta craft brewery is helping to save Georgia's most important trout stream.

American Rivers today released its annual list of America's Most Endangered Rivers, identifying ten rivers facing imminent threats. News

2019 Most Endangered Rivers

Fly Fisherman - April 16, 2019

American Rivers today released its annual list of America's Most Endangered Rivers,...

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Fly Fishing for Taimen in Mongolia

Fly Fishing for Taimen in Mongolia

Finding giant Mongolia taimen and a state of enlightenment.

Casting Backhand in Tight Quarters

Casting Backhand in Tight Quarters

A backhand cast is when you use your backcast to deliver the fly.

Bahamas - Bonefish

Bahamas - Bonefish

Conway casts for his personal best bonefish while fishing the Grand Bahama islands.

See more Popular Videos

Trending Stories

American River California United States

American River California

MIchael Wier - March 23, 2017

American River California

Fly-Fisherman Editor Ross Purnell shares his top five best trout fishing destinations in the world. Worldwide

5 Best Trout Fishing Spots in the World

Ross Purnell, Editor

Fly-Fisherman Editor Ross Purnell shares his top five best trout fishing destinations in the...

Read about Colorado's backcountry fly fishing in United States

Indian Peaks Wilderness Area Colorado

Steven B. Schweitzer - May 03, 2016

Read about Colorado's backcountry fly fishing in " Indian Peaks Wilderness Area Colorado."

See More Stories

More Conservation

Joe Hemming is the 2019 Conservationist of the year. Conservation

Joe Hemming: 2019 Conservationist of the Year

Josh Greenberg - January 02, 2019

Joe Hemming is the 2019 Conservationist of the year.

Resurrecting Hat Creek Conservation

More than a bridge over troubled waters.

Chip O' Brien | Photography by R. Valentine Atkinson - February 11, 2019

Resurrecting Hat Creek

See More Conservation

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction.

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.